FightFans / WWE / Most Controversial WWE Moments Ever: CM Punk, Undertaker, HBK and more

Most Controversial WWE Moments Ever: CM Punk, Undertaker, HBK and more

Last updated

The world of WWE is as much about high-octane drama as it is about athletic prowess. Over the years, this universe of wrestling entertainment has seen its fair share of moments that have sparked controversy, debate, and sometimes, outright shock.

Here, we delve into some of the most controversial moments in WWE history, exploring the events that have left an indelible mark on the industry.

What Are The Most Controversial Moments in WWE History?

The End of the Undertaker’s Streak

Imagine a legacy, two decades in the making, coming to an abrupt end. That’s precisely what happened at WrestleMania when Brock Lesnar defeated The Undertaker, ending his 21-year winning streak.

This moment wasn’t just a loss in a match; it was the end of an era. The decision, taken by Vince McMahon, sparked widespread analysis and debate among fans and critics alike.

YouTube video

CM Punk’s ‘Pipebomb’

Words can be as powerful as any wrestling move, and CM Punk’s ‘Pipebomb’ promo is a testament to that. Punk’s scathing critique of the company and its management, delivered with a blend of reality and fiction, blurred the lines of scripted entertainment.

This moment stands out not just for its content but for its delivery, leaving fans questioning what was real and what wasn’t.

The Curtain Call: Breaking Kayfabe

In an industry where the lines between reality and fiction are often blurred, the ‘Curtain Call’ incident in 1996 was a significant moment.

Shawn Michaels, Triple H, Kevin Nash, and Scott Hall, known collectively as The Kliq, broke character in front of a live audience, shattering the illusion of kayfabe.

This unscripted display of camaraderie among wrestlers with opposing on-screen personas was a bold move that had lasting implications for the industry.

The Tragic Death of Owen Hart

Among the controversies that have rocked WWE, few are as heart-wrenching as the tragic death of Owen Hart. During a stunt at Over the Edge 1999, a malfunction led to Hart falling from a great height, leading to his untimely death.

This incident not only sent shockwaves through the WWE Universe but also raised serious questions about the safety measures in professional wrestling.

The Montreal Screwjob

Perhaps no other incident in WWE history encapsulates controversy quite like the Montreal Screwjob. In a highly charged match, Bret Hart was controversially deprived of the World Championship, leading to widespread speculation and debate.

This incident, involving a behind-the-scenes decision to change the match’s outcome without Hart’s consent, remains a pivotal moment in wrestling history.


What was the Montreal Screwjob?

  • The Montreal Screwjob was a controversial incident where Bret Hart was stripped of the World Championship in a manipulated match outcome.

Why was the end of The Undertaker’s streak controversial?

  • The Undertaker’s 21-year winning streak at WrestleMania was a significant part of WWE lore, and its end by Brock Lesnar was a shock to fans and a pivotal moment in WWE history.

What was CM Punk’s ‘Pipebomb’?

  • CM Punk’s ‘Pipebomb’ was a groundbreaking promo where he openly criticized WWE management, blurring the lines between scripted entertainment and real-life grievances.

What was the significance of the ‘Curtain Call’?

  • The ‘Curtain Call’ was significant for breaking kayfabe (the portrayal of staged events as real), as members of The Kliq showed real-life camaraderie in the ring, contrary to their on-screen personas.

How did Owen Hart’s death impact WWE?

  • Owen Hart’s death during a live event raised serious concerns about the safety of performers, leading to changes in safety protocols and a reevaluation of high-risk stunts in WWE.
Jake Skudder
Written by
Jake Skudder
Jake is an SEO-minded Combat Sports, Gaming and Pro Wrestling writer and successful Editor in Chief. He has more than ten years of experience covering mixed martial arts, pro wrestling and gaming across a number of publications, starting at SEScoops in 2012 under the name Jake Jeremy.